New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try it yet?
New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try it yet?
Hello,
Has anyone tried this material yet? I have no commercial ties with this company, just posting it in case someone is interested. I have been looking at what materials are available on the market that can be used on surfboards. I found the video below that shows a pickup drive over a surfboard LENGTH wise, with no apparent damage to the board. The material is cheaper than most high performance materials, and may be worth looking into. They claim it is 15-30% lighter than glass, and is cheaper than S-glass.
http://www.innegrity.com/surfboard/index.htm
"The surfboard was made with eps foam, 1 layer of Innegra™ and 1 layer of 4oz fiberglass, laminated with epoxy resin. We were very surprised how well the Innegra board took the driving over. We thought the best case would be the glass would hold up but the foam would compress. To our amazement there was no compression dents!”
http://www.innegrity.com/MarineComposites.htm
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
There's a whole world of advanced fibers and weaves out there.
mike@coilsurf.com http://coilsurf.com
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Hello Mike,
Very true, lots of materials out there, and I've never used any "Advanced Fibers", or even epoxy for that matter. The last board I built was in 1983, polyester and glass, and Kevlar was one of the newest and most advance availble materials.
I thought that the video was pretty impressive though, as any conventional polyester board would have quickly turned to roadkill with a truck rolling over it.
Regards,
Montie
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Somebody used it in the WMD thread.
I haven't tried myself but, like you, I'm pretty intrigued. There was a little feature about it in the August issue of Composites Technology magazine including comments from Greg Loehr. Definitely appears to have potential. But as has been pointed out, the choices with composites are endless. Sooooo many ways to skin a cat.
I have no commercial interest whatsoever. I get the Composites mag because it had a free online subscription and I figured why not. But for those interested, I think it's supposed to be available soon through Graphite Master.
Pite y Pase ........................................No Pase
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I may be incorrect, but I believe this is cloth is a variation of polyethylene. I think a major issue is adhesion, the resin may not stick very well to the cloth. Take a look at a table of modulus of elasticity though, and you will see polyethylene right up at the top.
Re: [scottc] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I only glanced at their literature but I'm pretty sure it was polyproplyene (PP) not polyethylene (PE). I have read that PP is subject to degradation from UV though, so query the clear board in the video (or maybe it was painted white?)
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
this is 2 oz
will let ya know?
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Plus One is using the fabric according to their website. Maybe he has a few tips for us.
I looked at all the data from their charts but I did not come up with a real clear picture of the pros/cons. It seems the resistance to impact damage is high, but am unsure about how much strength it adds to the lam. Any mech engineers out there that can translate?
Anyone know how well it wraps rails?
CJ
"
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Montie,
I am just now finishing a board with 4 oz plain weave Innegra S. The core is 1.9 # EPS stringerless (from block foam). I used a layer of 4 oz over the Innegra cloth top and bottom. It makes for a light board that is very durable with good flex. No vacuum bagging required. The Innegra cloth didn't seem especially difficult to wet out but don't plan on wrapping it around any hard edges. Its like Kevlar in that it doesn't sand. It makes a very bright white board and adhesion with epoxy is excellent. It is going to be a little more expensive than S glass I believe. Seems to have a lot of potential and is recyclable. BTW it is polyproplyene.
regards,
Dave_D
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Alright, I'll spill a little....
Since Eric and Kirk are THE fiber guys, they've seen it all.
Coil first tested this fiber in the Brasington's proprietary vac-lam process 2 years ago. Two boards went to Puerto Rico for long-term use. Lots of test panels using different weights and weaves also. I looked at some of them today.
Ballistic-tough, low specific gravity, small-diameter individual fibers. Sorta cream-colored, off-white (not transparent).
One of many choices....
mike@coilsurf.com http://coilsurf.com
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Hey MD, Aren't Island surfboards down at Ocean Sport's world?
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Hey...Nissan Pathfinder...Same as mine! Looks like fun.
There is a limit to how much any cloth alone will impart strength in one thin layer...
Polypropylene...that'd stretch rather than shatter...could be good on top of a nice bouncy EPS, but maybe too flexible...
And Dave-D..."does'nt sand" does'nt sound good. But obstacles are there to be overcome...
Got any spare Huie? I'd give it a bollocking.
Josh
www.joshdowlingshape.com
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
What's the dent quotient in a lam with a single layer of 4oz?
Re: [cj3] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
We did a bunch of SUP's with it. Very hard to work with and for rails on a shortboard you will need a vacuum. Does not wet out very easily. However it is strong and light. It was expensive. Very.
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Typical Properties:
INPUT YARN: High Modulus Polypropylene
FIBRE TYPE: 940 Denier Innegra™ S
WEAVE: 4 Shaft Satin
WEIGHT: 135 g/m² (Nominal)
THICKNESS: 0.34 mm (Nominal)
WIDTHS: 685 & 1000 mm (Nominal)
FINISH: Loomstate
ROLL LENGTH: 100 mtrs (Nominal)
PACKAGING: Full width rolled on tube
plastic wrapped and packed
in cardboard carton
Options:
Alternate widths, lengths and tracers available on
request
Applications:
* Composite laminates using
Epoxy, Polyester or Vinyl ester
resin systems.
High Performance Composite Reinforcement
Issue Date 23/3/09
Features & Benefits:
* Good drapeablilty & easy to handle
* Fast wet out capabilities
* Cost effective
* Very low density (lightweight)
* High tensile modulus
* Increases impact resistance
* High wear & toughness (not brittle)
* Chemical, Water & UV resistant
* Excellent dielectric properties
ENGINEERED TEXTILES WOVEN IN AUSTRALIA
hey josh i will e mail you monday
fellas this is not the same fabric that was doing the rounds a year or so ago?
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I will cruise by the shop and check out the material. Maybe we used slightly different stuff? It was hard to wet out and the rails took a lot of care to make the laps? Not production friendly from a conventional point of view. However we did all the layups by hand. The end results was great as far as strenght/weight ratios. The material was made in North Carolina and is US Patent.
Huie here's the PD:
SD
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Josh,
Since it is plastic it just wants to fuzz up. I had a spot or two where I sanded through and I just did a small repair over the area. The stuff I used came out super white and was somewhat transparent. I will take some pics today.
Dave
Re: [guywhocantsurf] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone ...
g-w-c-s,
Roy at Ocean Sports World is a distributor for the cloth. He has been building with the stuff for a year or so. I believe it was one of his boards that is shown under the truck.
Dave_D
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, Kevlar sanding
Hello Gents,
Good to see some sharing of information here. One note on Armid (Kevlar) fiber finishing/sanding. I work for a cable manufacturer; one of our products is a 100 metric ton break strength cable for a marine application which uses Aramid fibers for the stress member. We build cable cross section samples on occasion, and yes the Kevlar is very difficult to work with, it frays/fuzzes when you grind it, it frays when you sand it also.
I recently used our metallurgical lab for prepping samples. A diamond saw with water makes a pretty clean cut on the Kevlar (slow cutting speed). I have also used our metallographic polisher to further clean up the samples. It is a horizontally mounted sanding disc that has a constant flow of water onto the surface of the sand paper. I don't recall what grit I started with (about 220?), but with the water flowing on the sandpaper the Kevlar does not fuzz up. I worked up on grit finish to about 600-800 grit and the Kevlar polished up nicely.
I have no idea if this could help on a surfboard, perhaps a small amount of water flowing across the glassed board and wet sanding by hand or disc could work. I would not experiment on a board with this, perhaps a piece of scrap. No guarantees but it may work.
Best regards,
Montie
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Thanks Dave. I thought that was one of their boards. I would assume this cloth would not be as good on painted foam since it has been described as somewhat transparent and whitish?
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Huie.. i have almost finished my first whole roll of the stuff. my glasser hates it as its like violane to wrap around rails. we always put under 1 layer of 4oz. first impressions were it has a high dent resistance but after a couple months i would now say it has a high dent Resiliance. it is reasonably opaque and i have used it over foam sprays. it tends to soften the color a little. the weave look is prominent. i have been calling it "Ghost carbon" as to customers it looks like carbon or kevlar but white. my favourite thing about it is that it does not seem to alter the flex feelings of a board compared to the difference you normally get with carbon "stiffer etc". so carry on boys enjoy testing! oh josh contact Colan direct
am of the opinion that my life's work belongs to the surfboard riding community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to make the most enjoyable, creative & best performing surf shapes for those who choose to care about them....
find out more about our boards at www.diversesurf.com.au
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
. so carry on boys enjoy testing!??
so dave you mean we are wasting our time jeez''
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Sounds like a good candidate for vac bag laminating to me.
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I am just curious, is there a specific ( or a few different ) online catalog or suppliers for various, for materials like this? I had a shortboard done with a kevlar deck patch, not vacuumed by Todd Proctor and the thing is crazy indestructable.
T.
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Maybe DAVE wants to keep it for himself so he's trying to throw us off the bus?
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
my glasser hates it as its like violane to wrap around rails.
i dont understand ? volane glass was all we ever used once
seems like time has softened some glassers haa''
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Huie, i think its the heat treatment thats made my glassers soft... (they work upstairs in a tin factory) haha. i thought i gave some clear feedback on my experiances with Inegra. i actually like it to use on boards. but like anything a little different to the norm you have to adapt your techniques to suit it. it definilty does suit vacuum bagging and some of those nice projects you do Huie.
am of the opinion that my life's work belongs to the surfboard riding community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to make the most enjoyable, creative & best performing surf shapes for those who choose to care about them....
find out more about our boards at www.diversesurf.com.au
Re: [feraldave] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Huie, i think its the heat treatment thats made my glassers soft... (they work upstairs in a tin factory) haha. i thought i gave some clear feedback on my experiances with Inegra. i actually like it to use on boards. but like anything a little different to the norm you have to adapt your techniques to suit it. it definilty does suit vacuum bagging and some of those nice projects you do Huie.
yes dave from what i can see so far you are spot on.
the 2 oz fills in a link for me in vac baging
but i want to see how well it goes for ''deck destroyers'' with p u epoxy & even pu pe
i feel like a truck driving test coming on haaa''
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
feraldave,
do you have any tips on what to do differently when glassing?
do you use innegra and standard 4oz together and if so do you wet them out at the same time?
i have some samples of the 2 and 4oz to try for my next one and as i only do 1 a year i dont want to stuff it up.
what would be the optimal usage for it if i have some 1.5lb eps? i am tossing up between just the cloth and epoxy or doing a bamboo veneer in between the innegra and 4oz.
thanks,
Scot
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Feraldave,
In addition...
We've (i.e. the "professor who is mentoring me and me the inept grasshopper) just done one with innegra under 4oz. This made rail wrap easy and removed issues sanding the lap.
Any suggestions for how to get innegra into both top and bottom lams?
Also, if the innegra is really flexy, should the blank have a bit of stiffness (i.e. no stringerless 1.5lb EPS)
I appreciate your time, thanks,
Red
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
On the WMD thread Huie mentioned doing a 2oz prelam of this stuff and using it like a veneer. This is something I've been kicking around since this thread came up. I like the idea of bagging on a veneer but to be honest the idea of a transparent or semi-transparent cloth-based veneer is a lot more visually appealing TO ME than using the various woods.
Originally my thought was to just bag the cloth directly onto the deck and bottom like an insert without even trying to wrap the rails, or perhaps just skip the bag altogether and wet lam them, and then do a regular wet lam with the outer glass as usual.
I have several questions - Does anyone have an opinion of how a layer of this 2oz or (if available) 4oz compares to a layer of the bamboo? Is there a strength or compression advantage to doing a prelam of it and then bagging that vs bagging a wet lam directly into the deck or bottom? If you did do a prelam would it wrap to the contour of the deck or bottom when bagged?
I've got two boards that are ready for glassing right now and I wanna try this stuff but I don't want to reinvent the wheel if I can help it. If anyone has any input to share I'd greatly appreciate it. If not then I guess I'll just pull the trigger and let you know how it goes.
Re: [gdaddy] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Follow Huie's advice!
Re: [gdaddy] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
On the WMD thread Huie mentioned doing a 2oz prelam of this stuff and using it like a veneer. This is something I've been kicking around since this thread came up. I like the idea of bagging on a veneer but to be honest the idea of a transparent or semi-transparent cloth-based veneer is a lot more visually appealing TO ME than using the various woods.
whoa '' i sugested this as a thought not tried. i wil try it this week if you can wait or you could vac a skin up & see how y wil lay
but i cant see why it wont be as flexy as any wood skin my reasons may be different than what you are seeking??
Originally my thought was to just bag the cloth directly onto the deck and bottom like an insert without even trying to wrap the rails, or perhaps just skip the bag altogether and wet lam them, and then do a regular wet lam with the outer glass as usual.
just follow what the boys have been doing here just leave out the boo or wood.
I have several questions - Does anyone have an opinion of how a layer of this 2oz or (if available) 4oz compares to a layer of the bamboo? Is there a strength or compression advantage to doing a prelam of it and then bagging that vs bagging a wet lam directly into the deck or bottom? If you did do a prelam would it wrap to the contour of the deck or bottom when bagged?
i would not try to wrap rails with it
I've got two boards that are ready for glassing right now and I wanna try this stuff but I don't want to reinvent the wheel if I can help it. If anyone has any input to share I'd greatly appreciate it. If not then I guess I'll just pull the trigger and let you know how it goes.
yea well thats howe we all can learn or you could let me wast my time & mony haa'' then again if i find something out of the box i may not tell
haa' its all good
will come back this week
huie
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Strange but I cant find any information on this product's thickness considering it would work best as a core in a sandwiched skin.
Other than potential to reduce a little weight, the pros (physicals) as compared to the cons (workability/cost) dont seem all that impressive. I could be wrong.
The truck video is impressive but very little is known about the board's actual construction. Ive done similar truck testing on bare eps foam. You'd be surprised how well the stuff holds up.
Having said that, I would like to sample the stuff. Would be good to know the weight and thickness.
I must say, it looks like the Coil boys have been getting similar field proven results for far longer.
_________________________________
As you slide down the banister of life,
don't let your arse collect too many splinters.
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
6 WOODS CLOSE
HUNTINGWOOD NSW
AUSTRALIA 2148
TEL: +(61 2) 9672 7888
FAX: +(61 2) 9672 7666
WEB: www.colan.com.au
Typical Properties:
INPUT YARN: High Modulus Polypropylene
FIBRE TYPE: 940 Denier Innegra™ S
WEAVE: 4 Shaft Satin
WEIGHT: 135 g/m² (Nominal)
THICKNESS: 0.34 mm (Nominal)
WIDTHS: 685 & 1000 mm (Nominal)
FINISH: Loomstate
ROLL LENGTH: 100 mtrs (Nominal)
PACKAGING: Full width rolled on tube
plastic wrapped and packed
in cardboard carton
Options:
Alternate widths, lengths and tracers available on
request
Applications:
* Composite laminates using
Epoxy, Polyester or Vinyl ester
resin systems.
All information contained in this publication is based upon tests carried out by Colan Products, independent testing authorities or other suppliers. This information is believed to be correct and
reliable at time of printing. Colan requires that users establish the suitability of all products for their applications and assume all risks.
COLAN ANG210
High Performance Composite Reinforcement
Issue Date 23/3/09
Features & Benefits:
* Good drapeablilty & easy to handle
* Fast wet out capabilities
* Cost effective
* Very low density (lightweight)
* High tensile modulus
* Increases impact resistance
* High wear & toughness (not brittle)
* Chemical, Water & UV resistant
* Excellent dielectric properties
ENGINEERED TEXTILES WOVEN IN AUSTRALIA BY
COLAN PRODUCTS, AN AUSTRALIAN COMPAN
crafty thats the 4oz
6 WOODS CLOSE
HUNTINGWOOD NSW
AUSTRALIA 2148
TEL: +(61 2) 9672 7888
FAX: +(61 2) 9672 7666
WEB: www.colan.com.au
Typical Properties:
INPUT YARN: High Modulus Polypropylene
FIBRE TYPE: 625 Denier Innegra™ S
WEAVE: Plain
WEIGHT: 68 g/m² (Nominal)
THICKNESS: 0.2 mm (Nominal)
WIDTHS: 760 & 1000 mm (Nominal)
FINISH: Loomstate
ROLL LENGTH: 100 mtrs (Nominal)
PACKAGING: Full width rolled on tube
plastic wrapped and packed
in cardboard carton
Options:
Alternate widths, lengths and tracers available on
request
Applications:
* Composite laminates using
Epoxy, Polyester or Vinyl ester
resin systems.
All information contained in this publication is based upon tests carried out by Colan Products, independent testing authorities or other suppliers. This information is believed to be correct and
reliable at time of printing. Colan requires that users establish the suitability of all products for their applications and assume all risks.
COLAN ANG209
High Performance Composite Reinforcement
Issue Date 23/3/09
Features & Benefits:
* Good drapeablilty & easy to handle
* Fast wet out capabilities
* Cost effective
* Very low density (lightweight)
* High tensile modulus
* Increases impact resistance
* High wear & toughness (not brittle)
* Chemical, Water & UV resistant
* Excellent dielectric properties
ENGINEERED TEXTILES WOVEN IN AUSTRALIA BY
COLAN PRODUCTS, AN AUSTRALIAN COMPAN
thats 2 oz yea under the skins patches
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Thanks Huie.
Its 2X thicker than regular 4oz E. Thats good.
Visually, how dense is the weave? Tight mesh or open? Weight would depend on how much resin it takes.
Looks like one would need two layers of 4oz to make a bamboo equivalent thickness.
Has potential but in the end workability is a big factor.
_________________________________
As you slide down the banister of life,
don't let your arse collect too many splinters.
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
interested to try some as deck patches with the lightest blank I can get.....
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Just remember that sandwich thickness is key to sandwich strength (i.e. separation of the layers). I think the veneers work because they are 0.4-0.6mm thick, rather than their inherent strength/flexibility. Of course I'm often wrong...
Re: [pridmore] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Ineggra
Re: [surfding] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
heres a cple pics so far it is the best polyprpolene i have used
but ferel dave has summed it up best not the best for production'' hard to cut a clean edge.
so fwiw heres an inlay this board is 4 1/2 lb sanded so the innegra 2oz with a 4oz plan weave over has not given me any weight prbs
the deck feels mighty tough so know i will give it to the deck destroyers see what goes?
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
mmm. nice Huie. i think i might get you down here one day to do some finish coat lessons to my production staff! i too use innegra under 4oz. only way i would use it on a bottom is vacuum bagged...
am of the opinion that my life's work belongs to the surfboard riding community, and as long as I live it is my privilege to make the most enjoyable, creative & best performing surf shapes for those who choose to care about them....
find out more about our boards at www.diversesurf.com.au
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Huie I am extremely impressed!
Great work on your part.
Your the man and much respect for the man down under!
Surfding
Re: [surfding] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Huie what foam did you use on that board ?,I did a test board on the weekend with 4 ozs innegra on the deck with 4ozs glass bottom and a 4 ozs glass over the innegra on the deck ,I used xps foam on this one ,6' 2 X 17,7/8 X 1,7/8 .finnished board with glass on fins came in at 2.1 kgs ,(all the glassing was done in one hit ,)
Re: [Leigh] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
hey leigh your boards look allright eh.
yea the board in pic is 5' 10'' x 18'' x 21/8''
one big difference c d d blank
Re: [huie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
c d d is the best kept secrete on the planet.
CORE is critical.
Re: [surfding] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
Looove the look of that cloth under glass. I'm really interested in the cdd blank, too, but I'm geographically undesirable for that option.
Is that an epoxy layup?
Re: [gdaddy] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
The world will never know C D D it will be a ledgend like the man who created it!
Re: [feraldave] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
i tried a blend that every other strand in the cloth is fiberglass so wet out was pretty easy - the fiberglass cloth wet out but the innegra does not - gives a cool look - maybe easzier to work with for a hand layup than the 100% innegra?
is the stuff you guys are using 100% of the polypro material?
i posted a couple pics of the board in the wmd thread (it has a bamboo deck).........
http://grasshoppersurfboards.blogspot.com/
Re: [grasshopper] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I am making one now with this cloth.
I have lamed the 4oz Ineggra layer over the whole board, had a few hangers - the cloth does not like to be sanded. I brought it up to a 600grit and it looked like normal. dropped the probox in and I should be done by the weekend. I am going to put 4oz E over the cloth. I had bubbles from the tail edge where the cloth did not lap correctly so that was a pain to fix but the other lap took care of it after sanding.
So far it seems relatively strong, my finger does not dent the board if pressed down (to an extent) but I do not think the fiber that I am using is the tightest that they have. It looks more like a volan and loose weave.
Ill post up some pics when I get finished.
HOLLA
Re: [fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
a rail lap good fun eh dave''
innegra
Re: [Fullmontie] New cloth material Ineggra S, anyone try ...
I wonder how new this material really is or in what way it is new. Innegra S is made of polypropylene, according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyolefin "Polypropylene is another common polyolefin which is made from the olefin propylene." On http://oneoceankayaks.com/Abrasion.htm#synanch they tested olefin cloths in september 2000 according to wayback machine, including a polypropylene cloth. So I wonder what is the difference between Innegra S and other polyolefin and polypropylene cloths. That said, it's great if this new product makes this types of cloth easier to obtain and get acceptance in surfboard construction.
http://www.boardcad.org - The open source CAD software for surfboards